North Carolina sets tougher power terms for big data centers than the tech giants had agreed to
North Carolina has given AI data center developers a clear answer on who carries the risk of the power plants built for them: mostly the developers. In orders issued Monday, the state's Utilities Commission approved a new rate schedule for data centers on Duke Energy's grid. Its terms are stricter than a settlement Duke negotiated with its biggest tech customers in October.
The stakes are large. Duke is one of the largest US utilities, and its Duke Energy Carolinas unit has signed service contracts for 6.7 gigawatts of new heavy-use customers, 92% of them data centers, WFAE reported. The terms set here shape what it costs to build data centers in the state.
What the order requires
The new schedule covers data centers that need 50 megawatts or more. According to Duke's own filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, the order mixes terms from the October settlement with requirements the commission added on its own.
Data centers over 100 megawatts must sign contracts of at least 15 years. They will be billed for at least 75% of the capacity they contract for, whether they use it or not. That is a "minimum bill": it protects the utility if a customer scales back. The 75% floor was already part of the October settlement.
Developers must pay upfront for equipment that serves only them, such as a dedicated substation. They must back shared transmission upgrades with a letter of credit, a bank guarantee the utility can draw on. Some of those upgrade costs will be assigned directly to the data center, using a method still to be set. The order also sets penalties for early exit and interim rules allowing power cuts to these customers.
The most consequential new term is a "stranded generation charge." A power plant becomes stranded when the customer it was built for leaves before the plant is paid off. Under the order, data centers must post security and make an extra payment when their contract ends. The exact formula will come later.
The gap it addresses is stark. Duke's new gas turbines are expected to cost $3.2 billion and last about 35 years, Charlotte public radio station WFAE reported. Minimum data center contracts run 10 to 15 years. As a placeholder, WFAE reported, a developer on a 15-year contract must post collateral covering the turbine's remaining 20 years.
The commission wrote that otherwise these risks would fall on existing ratepayers, "who have no responsibility" for them, according to WFAE. Large data centers are projected to make up 9.2% of peak demand at Duke Energy Carolinas by 2035, WFAE reported.
How it differs from the tech companies' deal
In October, Duke filed a settlement with the state's consumer advocate, Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft, an industrial customers' group and the Defense Department. It required upfront payments for dedicated equipment and deposits for shared upgrades. But under that deal, some transmission costs would have been spread across all customers first and repaid over the life of each data center's contract, WFAE reported at the time. Environmental groups said it did not cover new power plants.
The commission did not approve that deal as filed. Its version has data centers pay more of the transmission and connection costs, WFAE reported, and adds the stranded generation charge. Duke told investors in a securities filing that it is still assessing the data center portion and will work with stakeholders on putting it in place.
Not everyone thinks the rules go far enough. Commissioner Donald van der Vaart partly dissented. He wrote that the majority's approach rests on a hope that a data center will stay for the life of the plants built to serve it. Two other commissioners argued the tariff should cover all large power users, not just data centers, according to Energy News Beat's summary of the orders.
Clean energy and consumer groups were split. The Environmental Defense Fund called the order strong on data center cost risk, and the North Carolina Sustainable Energy Association said it does not yet guarantee data centers pay all their costs, WFAE reported. Gov. Josh Stein said the overall rate increase is too high and that the state still needs a separate rate class so data centers clearly pay for their own energy use, WLOS reported.
What it means for buyers and investors
For the largest cloud companies and data center developers, North Carolina just got more expensive to commit to. Fifteen-year terms, minimum bills and collateral tie up capital and reduce the option to walk away if AI demand cools. That flexibility is exactly what regulators decided ratepayers should not underwrite.
For Duke shareholders, the picture is mixed. The same orders approved residential rate increases of roughly 9% to 10% over two years, starting January 1. But the allowed return on equity, the profit rate regulators let Duke earn on its investments, was set at 9.8%. Duke had first asked for nearly 11%. Duke expects a one-time pre-tax charge of $10 million at each of its two North Carolina utilities this quarter, according to its securities filing.
The commission also approved Duke's long-term resource plan, Axios reported. It includes about 3.8 gigawatts of new gas plants between 2030 and 2033 and keeps some coal plants running to 2040. Plants like these are what the stranded generation charge is meant to cover.
Several details remain open: the stranded charge formula, how transmission costs are split and how Duke implements the schedule. Developers will lobby on each. For now, North Carolina is telling the AI industry that if it wants power plants built on its timeline, it has to guarantee the bill.