AI Momentum 104.8 +2.6%GitHub Pulse 5171 -5.9%Capital Flow $206.5B +5650.2%Hiring Heatmap 0.0 -100.0%
Advertisement
Talent & Organizations

Executives at the Fed's AI forum described retraining, not layoffs. Warsh's staff is modeling job losses anyway

Executives who spoke at a Federal Reserve forum on Monday described AI changing who they hire, not driving layoffs. Affirm's chief executive said his company has made no AI layoffs. Others described fewer hires in back-office roles, growth in sales and engineering, and existing workers retrained on the job.

The setting gave those comments weight. The forum, hosted by the San Francisco Fed, was the first hearing of a Fed task force on productivity and jobs. Fed Chair Kevin Warsh said AI will matter for interest-rate policy "down the road." In his opening remarks, he said Fed staff have begun modeling several AI outcomes, including one where the economy grows faster while unemployment rises.

Reassuring accounts from executives and contingency planning at the central bank: that gap matters for anyone setting headcount plans or betting on AI-driven margins in 2027.

What the executives said

The first panel, moderated by Warsh, featured Stripe CEO Patrick Collison, Affirm CEO Max Levchin and Palo Alto Networks CEO Nikesh Arora, according to the San Francisco Fed's agenda.

Collison was the most specific about where hiring is shrinking. According to a published transcript of the session, he said Stripe is seeing "substantially reduced hiring" for general and administrative roles, meaning support functions such as finance, legal and HR. He said those costs are falling quickly as a share of revenue.

In engineering and sales, the transcript shows, he said Stripe is seeing acceleration instead. Because AI makes new product features cheaper to build, Stripe wants more of them, and it makes sense to hire more sellers. AI reduces the need for staff in one part of the company and raises their value in another.

Collison also offered a warning. Per the transcript, he said many people in the AI industry expect software "drop-in remote workers" within 12 months: agents that can join a chat or video call and do what a person at a keyboard does.

Levchin said Affirm's engineers are roughly five times more productive and that the company has made "zero layoffs due to AI," per the transcript. That repeats a pledge he made to analysts in May. He added that companies are holding tight to their AI researchers, whom the big AI labs may try to lure with higher pay.

Arora described "a gradual reskilling" at Palo Alto Networks, saying every employee now experiments with AI, according to the transcript. He used a 3,000-person customer-support team as an example of AI supporting human agents, and said customer service is not a job he wants for young people in future. In cybersecurity, he said, the problem is the opposite: in the last six months there has been almost no outside talent available to call on.

A later panel, moderated by San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly, heard a similar account from health care. Providence CEO Erik Wexler said AI's gains are arriving now, with doctors reporting two to four hours a day saved on paperwork, Becker's Hospital Review reported. He said Providence is still hiring and trying to raise workers' skills.

Economist John Cochrane, who attended, summed up the business leaders in a blog post: none of them were firing. He also relayed a figure from Indeed chief economist Svenja Gudell: about two-thirds of job postings that mention AI are for non-technical roles.

Why the Fed is planning for worse

Warsh's opening remarks set out three scenarios that he called "illustrative scenarios, not forecasts," according to Decrypt. Yahoo Finance and the AP reported the same three cases.

In the first, AI gains are widely shared and employment stays near full. In the second, AI replaces some jobs rather than helping people do them, so unemployment climbs even as growth runs above average. In the third, AI spending fails to pay off, stock prices fall and unemployment rises more sharply. The economy recovers, but without the promised productivity gains.

The Associated Press reported that Warsh acknowledged risks including widespread job loss, alongside a more hopeful case in which AI speeds innovation. He did not discuss any change in interest rates, the AP noted.

The Fed now uses the label "superintelligence," or SI, for advanced AI. Decrypt notes this is official Fed wording, not a finding that today's AI outthinks humans. The forum feeds one of five task forces Warsh set up. Its members include investor Marc Andreessen and Stanford economist Charles Jones, now on leave at Anthropic, Yahoo Finance reported.

Not everyone on stage shared the concern. In the final session, Andreessen told the audience not to worry about employment, arguing that government already heavily protects workers, Cochrane wrote. Former Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo struck a different note, saying ordinary Americans view AI with fear.

What it means for employers and investors

The executives' accounts match the labor data so far. In its 2027 outlook, reported by Fortune on Monday, Goldman Sachs said layoffs stayed historically low this year. It expects a "low-hire, low-fire" job market to last another year, with AI displacement hitting harder after that.

Goldman economist Joseph Briggs has estimated that up to 9% of workers could eventually be displaced, with the disruption speeding up in a downturn. That is the risk Monday's testimony does not rule out.

A freeze on back-office hiring shrinks a workforce without any layoff announcement. The roles are simply never posted. If that spreads, it would show up first as fewer openings for graduates and career switchers, not as headlines.

For boards, the lesson is that "no AI layoffs" and "fewer jobs" can both be true. For investors, Warsh's third scenario is a reminder that the central bank is now modeling an AI investment bust alongside an AI jobs shock.

Caveats apply. The executives' claims are self-reported, come from companies with reason to sound responsible before regulators, and none came with detailed headcount figures. Several of the quotes come from a third-party transcript, not an official Fed record. The Fed's next rate-setting meeting is in December.