AI Momentum 107.6 +2.7%GitHub Pulse 5172 -5.9%Capital Flow $204.6B +5804.2%Hiring Heatmap 0.0 -100.0%
Advertisement
Enterprise Adoption

Chicago and Los Angeles schools say they may drop Google Search because Google won't offer it without AI

Google has told US schools that from early next year they can have its search engine only with its AI built in. Some of its biggest school customers now say they would rather switch search engines than accept that.

Chicago Public Schools told families in a November 13 letter that it wants Google Search without the AI features. If it cannot get that, it says it will "look to other search solutions." This week, Los Angeles Unified confirmed it has switched off Google's AI summaries for students and is reviewing whether Google Search belongs in its classrooms at all.

Los Angeles's chief information officer, Jack Kelanic, told a school board committee the district could change the default search engine on its school devices "literally overnight," according to the New York Times. The Times reported on November 18 that New York City, the country's largest district, is in the same position. Its schools chancellor, Kamar Samuels, told the paper the city will explore other options if Google does not reconsider.

Some districts are looking at Microsoft's Bing and DuckDuckGo, which both let administrators turn off AI-generated answers, the Times reported. No district has switched yet.

For any organization buying software, this is an early, public test of a growing problem. Vendors are folding AI into products customers already depend on, and the option to say no is shrinking. Schools have stronger reasons than most buyers to refuse, and a louder platform to do it.

What Google is offering, and what it is not

On November 3, Google said its AI products for students would be switched off by default next year. That covers Gemini, its chatbot, plus Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Search itself. School administrators would have to turn each one on. Google presented this as giving schools more control.

The catch is Search. Schools can leave the Gemini apps off and still use Search. But Search arrives with AI Overviews, the AI-written summaries at the top of results, and AI Mode, a chatbot-style version of search. Google says it will not make a school version without them.

"Search and AI are deeply integrated," said Chris Phillips, Google's vice president for education. Students at a school that blocks AI entirely will see a message saying Search is not available.

Google's pitch to schools is Guided Learning, an AI tutor that walks students through problems step by step rather than handing over answers.

Critics call it leverage. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said Google was "trying to use its monopoly power" to push AI into public schools. Senator Ed Markey wrote to Google's chief executive, Sundar Pichai, asking whether an AI-free Search is technically feasible. He also asked how many districts already restrict student AI use. He wants answers by November 30.

Why Google may not bend

Google has not said publicly why it will not offer schools Search without AI. One unproven theory, raised to NPR by a former Google employee, is legal. She points to recent antitrust cases brought by publishers, in which a judge treated Search and its AI answers as one integrated product. In her view, a schools-only off switch could suggest the two can be separated. Google did not answer NPR's questions about any such link, and the antitrust experts NPR consulted were not fully convinced.

The commercial stakes are also clear. Google had about 85% of the US search market in October, according to StatCounter data cited by eMarketer, against under 2% for DuckDuckGo. School is where many people form their search habits. eMarketer argues that an AI-or-nothing stance risks pushing students toward rivals for years.

Switching is not free, though. Chicago's schools run on Google Classroom, Drive and Docs, and its Chromebooks are closely tied to Gemini, the Chicago Sun-Times reported. Replacing all of that would be a major undertaking. An Electronic Frontier Foundation technologist told EdSource that long contracts, retraining and staff time make leaving Google costly for districts.

Changing only the search engine is much cheaper, which is why the threat is credible. It is a setting on devices the district already manages. Chicago also says it is exploring ways to suppress the AI summaries itself while keeping Google Search.

What buyers should watch

The next marker is Markey's November 30 deadline. Google's new defaults take effect early next year. Districts must decide before then whether to opt in, filter the AI out with outside tools, or move students to another search engine.

Keep the skepticism. These are threats, not cancellations. Google's tools sit deep inside school operations, and a search-engine switch touches only a small part of that relationship. Google could also blunt the backlash with a narrower concession short of a full AI-free Search.

But the episode shows where buyer leverage sits. Large customers are pushing back in public, before the bundle is locked in, and naming specific alternatives. Companies weighing AI features added to software they already pay for face a version of the same question. Can they turn the AI off, and what do they lose if they do?