Anthropic ends its first trading day up 17%, after giving back half of its opening jump
Anthropic's shares closed their first day on Nasdaq at $97.17, up about 17% from the $83 price set for its initial public offering. That is a solid gain for buyers who got shares in the deal. It is also well short of where the stock started.
Trading under the ticker ANT began just before noon Eastern time, more than two hours after the market opened. The first trade came at $111.50, 34% above the offer price. Within a minute the stock touched about $115, then began a slide that took it as low as $92.72 in the early afternoon.
For investors, the shape of the day matters more than the headline gain. Buyers who paid the opening price ended the day down about 13%. And the rest of the AI sector, which had rallied in the morning on hopes the debut would revive interest in AI stocks, ended lower.
Heavy trading, a smaller valuation by the close
Demand at the open was enormous. The opening trade alone covered about 108 million shares worth roughly $12 billion, Yahoo Finance calculated. About $15 billion changed hands in the first minute, nearly twice the first-minute total for SpaceX's debut in June.
By the close, about 805 million shares had traded, according to Google Finance data. That equals more than four-fifths of the 980 million shares sold in the offering, a sign of very heavy turnover.
The company's market value depends on which share count is used. Google Finance put it at about $1.27 trillion at the close, in line with the roughly 13.2 billion shares of all classes that StockTitan and TradingKey cite from the prospectus. On a fully diluted basis, which adds shares promised through options and similar awards, the opening price briefly valued Anthropic at about $2 trillion. At the closing price, that fully diluted figure falls to roughly $1.76 trillion, by machine.net's calculation using the roughly 18.1 billion fully diluted shares cited by TradingKey.
The close also settles how much money Anthropic left on the table, meaning the gap between what it received and what the market paid on day one. At $97.17, that comes to about $13.9 billion across the 980 million shares sold, by machine.net's calculation. Yahoo Finance had noted that a close above about $98 would have topped SpaceX's $14.4 billion, the largest such gap on a list of US IPOs since 1985 kept by University of Florida professor Jay Ritter.
Some skeptics remain unmoved. New York University valuation professor Aswath Damodaran put Anthropic's value at $76 a share in a blog post on Wednesday, before pricing. The closing price is still about 28% above his estimate.
The rest of the AI trade went the other way
The broader market told a gloomier story. Stocks rose in the morning, with Nasdaq futures up about 1.6% before the open. By the close the Nasdaq Composite and the S&P 500 were each down about 2% and the Dow had fallen about 1,100 points, ending below 50,000, according to Yahoo Finance and TipRanks.
AI-linked stocks gave up their early gains as Anthropic began to trade. Nvidia, up nearly 5% early on, was down 1% to 2% in the afternoon, according to the Associated Press, Reuters and Yahoo Finance. AI cloud provider CoreWeave swung from a gain of about 10% to a loss, the AP reported, and Reuters had it down 5%. Broadcom and Micron also turned lower.
Some individual investors appeared to sell other AI shares to raise cash for Anthropic, Yahoo Finance reported. Vanda Research's Viraj Patel said retail traders were "taking both sides rather than a one-way bid" in the new stock.
Other pressures had little to do with Anthropic. The 10-year Treasury yield sat above 5%, a level that makes borrowing for data centers more expensive. Traders are pricing in a likely Federal Reserve rate increase in December, according to CME futures data cited by Reuters. Bloomberg and the AP both cited lingering doubts that AI spending will earn enough to justify the debt behind it.
What investors are taking from it
Market strategists largely split the deal's success from the market's direction. "The Anthropic IPO has been a major success," Matt Maley of Miller Tabak told Bloomberg, while adding that it does little to fix the market's bigger problems. Argent Capital portfolio manager Jed Ellerbroek told Reuters his expectations for data center spending growth have come down in the past month or two.
Dan Ives of Yorkville Ives has called the IPO a big near-term win for the tech sector. Capital Economics' Joe Maher argued that the stock's path over the coming months will be a better test of investor confidence in AI than one day's jump.
History supports caution on first-day prices. Yahoo Finance found that all 12 of the biggest US IPOs since 2008 fell below their first trade within a year. Anthropic already has, by the end of its first afternoon.
The bigger tests are still ahead: the company's first quarterly report as a public company, and the end of the lockup period, when early holders, who paid an average of about $11.50 a share according to Yahoo Finance, become free to sell.